Ich With Plants, Shrimp, and Snails: Treating It Without Meds
This one comes from my personal tank, not the shop's, and it isn't over yet. Not long after some new animals arrived, I found white spots on the fish. Ich. And the tank was full of exactly the things most ich treatments are hard on: live plants, shrimp, and snails. Here is what I did and where it stands now.
The new arrivals
I ordered three things I was excited about from a large online supplier: Indian ricefish (Oryzias dancena), a close cousin of the Japanese medaka the shop is built on and a species I had never kept before, plus blueberry snails and Indian zebra shrimp. The fish went straight into a planted tank I was proud of, along with the shrimp and snails.
Then the fish started showing little white dots, like someone had dusted them with salt.
It wasn't a surprise. This supplier has a reputation for ich in its tanks, and its reviews mention it more than once. Shipping isn't really the cause. The stress of a trip in a bag can bring out ich the fish already carried, which is why it often shows up one to three weeks after arrival, even on fish that looked perfect on day one. Ich can ride in on fish from anywhere, and it is the reason quarantine exists, which I will come back to.
What ich actually is
Ich isn't a fungus. Ich (Ichthyophthirius multifiliis) is a single-celled parasite, and it can only finish its life cycle with a live fish to feed on. That fact is what made heat worth trying.
It has three stages:
- On the fish: the white spot is the parasite feeding under the skin. Here it is protected, and medication in the water cannot touch it.
- On the bottom: it drops off, settles on gravel, glass, or plants, and forms a cyst that splits into hundreds of new parasites. Also well protected.
- Swimming free: those new parasites swim off looking for a fish, and they have to find one fast. This is the stage treatments can reliably reach.
Chemical treatments only reliably kill the free-swimming stage. The cysts on the bottom are protected, which is why gravel vacuuming matters so much: it pulls them out of the tank.
Good news for the invertebrate side of things: ich only infects fish. The shrimp and snails were never at risk from the parasite itself. They were only at risk from whatever I did about it.
Why the methylene blue stayed on the shelf
I already had an open bottle of methylene blue that I use for other things, and my first thought was that it would handle this. I had it filed in my head as an antiviral. That part was wrong: ich is not a virus, and methylene blue is not used as an antiviral in fishkeeping anyway. It is a dye with mild antiseptic and antifungal action, and it is a common hobby treatment for ich and other external parasites, though the hard evidence behind it for ich is thin. It is still on standby if this turns.
But the real reason I left it on the shelf was everything else living in that tank:
- The plants. Every time I have used methylene blue in a planted setup, I have lost plants. That is my experience, and the product labels warn about it too.
- The shrimp and snails. Shrimp and snails are much more sensitive than fish to many medications, copper above all. Some products say they are fine at label dose, and most guides still say to take shrimp and snails out first. It was risky enough that I was not willing to gamble with them.
- The filter. This is the one I did not fully appreciate until I looked it up. Methylene blue is hard on the beneficial bacteria that keep a tank cycled. Dosing the whole tank could have stalled the filter and given me an ammonia problem on top of an ich problem.
That lines up with the rule in my methylene blue guide: never dose your display tank. I had just never been this tempted to break it.
Why I treated the tank instead of moving the fish
The usual advice is a separate hospital tank, and it is good advice. I chose not to. Catching and moving sick fish is stressful, and stress weakens a fish's defenses against ich. And once infected fish have been in a tank, the cysts are already in that tank's gravel. Moving the fish out only clears the display if every fish leaves and the tank sits fishless long enough for the parasite to die off. So I decided to treat the whole tank, gently, in place, and keep everyone in the setup they were already settled in.
Turning up the heat
The tank had been sitting at 76°F, a comfortable middle ground for all three animals. The zebra shrimp's published keeping range covers both 76°F and 80°F, and my snails were comfortable through the change. For the ricefish, 80°F is near the top of what they are usually kept at, but still within it.
So I raised it to 80°F. If you try this, go up a degree or two a day, since shrimp handle sudden swings worse than steady warmth.
Here is what that does and does not do. Warmer water speeds up the parasite's life cycle. The spots mature and drop off the fish sooner, and the parasite reaches its free-swimming stage sooner, where it has to find a fish quickly or die. At 76°F the cycle was already fairly quick, and at 80°F it runs a little faster.
What 80°F does not do is kill ich. The often-quoted "heat cure" is around 86°F, and even that depends on the strain. At 80°F the parasite still reproduces. Heat here is a helper, not a cure.
So what is actually doing the work? Probably a few things at once. The faster cycle gets parasites off the fish sooner. The fish's own immune system matters a lot: fish that come through ich build real protection against it, though recovered fish can still carry a few parasites. And regular gravel cleaning pulls cysts out of a tank before they can hatch.
Where things stand
The spots are starting to clear, and every plant, shrimp, and snail is still alive and doing its thing. I am encouraged.
I am also not calling it cured. Spots fading is what ich does between waves, and a new round can show up a few days later. Until the tank has gone a good stretch with no new spots, this is "clearing so far," and I will update this page when I know more.
What to do to finish it safely
- Hold at 80°F, and keep up the gravel cleaning, for about 10 to 14 days past the last spot you see, not the day the fish look clean. That's the usual rule, because hidden cysts and free swimmers outlast the visible spots.
- Add aeration. Warm water holds less oxygen while fish need more, and ich damages gills. An air stone or a filter outlet pointed at the surface covers it.
- Vacuum the gravel and do partial water changes every day or two. The cysts sit on the bottom, and siphoning them out removes them before they hatch (the Merck Veterinary Manual recommends it). Keep the changes small, around 10 to 15 percent, and skim the top of the substrate instead of deep cleaning a planted tank. Match the new water's temperature and hardness and dechlorinate it, since sudden swings stress shrimp and can cause bad molts.
- Check the temperature with a separate thermometer, not just the heater dial. A heater that overshoots past 80°F is a bigger risk than the ich.
- Feed light. Less waste means cleaner water and more oxygen to go around.
- Watch the shrimp molt. Warmer water speeds up their metabolism and molting, so keep an eye out for any that struggle.
- Come back down slowly when it is over, a degree or two a day.
When this is not the right call
Medication isn't bad, and heat doesn't always work. Things are improving so far, in one tank, with one batch of fish, and I cannot say how much of that is the heat. Reach for a proper treatment, or a hospital tank, if:
- spots keep spreading or getting heavier after several days at the higher temperature
- fish are gasping at the surface, stop eating, or start dying
- the tank holds fish that cannot handle 80°F
- you have no plants or invertebrates to protect, in which case a labeled ich medication is the standard first move
If you do medicate a tank with shrimp, snails, or plants, check the label. Many ich medications contain copper, which most invertebrates will not survive. Salt is another old option, but plants and invertebrates may not tolerate it, so it belongs in a separate container. The sick medaka guide walks through the medication route.
The real lesson: quarantine
The best fix happens before any of this starts. A proper quarantine would very likely have kept this out of the planted tank. Fish from any source can carry ich without showing it, and shipping stress is what brings it out. Even fish that have recovered from ich can still carry it.
So: give new fish their own container for about a month (the University of Florida's extension service recommends at least 30 days); two weeks is the bare minimum. Rinse new plants and keep separate nets too, since the cysts are sticky and can hitch a ride. My arrival guide covers getting new fish settled.
Medication isn't always the first move. This time, knowing how ich works gave me a gentler option to try. Next time, a spare tub and a few weeks of patience come first.
Quick checklist: ich in a planted tank with invertebrates
- Confirm it is ich: flat, even white dots like grains of salt on the body and fins, often with fish scratching against surfaces. Fuzzy, raised tufts (often on the head or eyes) point to something else, like Epistylis, and heat can make that worse.
- Make sure every fish in the tank can handle about 80°F before you start.
- Raise the temperature a degree or two a day to about 80°F.
- Check the temperature with a separate thermometer, not just the heater dial.
- Add an air stone or surface agitation.
- Skim the gravel and change about 10 to 15 percent of the water every day or two.
- Match the new water's temperature and hardness, and dechlorinate it.
- Feed lightly.
- Hold the heat, and keep cleaning the gravel, about 10 to 14 days after the last spot.
- Switch to a labeled medication or hospital tank if it gets worse.
- Bring the temperature down slowly when you are done.
- Quarantine every new fish for about a month, and never less than two weeks.
Ordering from the shop? Give new fish their own container for a few weeks like any new arrival, and rinse the free-floating plants that come with live orders.
Shop Medaka VarietiesCommon questions
Can you treat ich without medication?
Sometimes, yes. Raising the temperature, cleaning the gravel, and changing water can help fish shed ich, and fish build immunity as they recover. It is not a guaranteed cure. If spots spread or fish decline, move to a labeled ich treatment.
Does 80°F kill ich?
No. At 80°F ich speeds through its life cycle but still reproduces. The heat helps by getting the parasite off the fish and into its weak free-swimming stage sooner. The often-quoted killing temperature is around 86°F, too warm for many tanks.
Is heat treatment safe for shrimp and snails?
Usually, if your species tolerate the temperature. Indian zebra shrimp have a published range that includes 80°F. Snails sold as "blueberry" can be different species, so check the range for yours. Raise it slowly, since shrimp handle swings worse than steady warmth, and add aeration.
Can I use methylene blue in a tank with shrimp and plants?
I would not. It is hard on plants, risky for invertebrates, and harms the bacteria in your filter. Methylene blue belongs in a separate container, not a display tank.
Can ich hurt my shrimp or snails?
No. Ich only infects fish. The risk to invertebrates comes from the treatment, especially copper-based medications.
How long should I keep the temperature up?
About 10 to 14 days after the last visible spot is the common rule. Spots disappearing does not mean the cysts on the bottom are gone, so do not stop the day the fish look clean.